


You Should Have Lied

by stars1029



Category: iCarly
Genre: Angst, Drama
Language: English
Status: Completed
Published: 2010-09-10
Updated: 2010-09-10
Packaged: 2014-05-04 12:54:53
Rating: K+
Chapters: 1
Words: 679
Publisher: www.fanfiction.net
Story URL: https://www.fanfiction.net/s/6314194/1/
Author URL: https://www.fanfiction.net/u/2121057/stars1029
Summary: I walked out of my senior prom with his voice shouting for me to come back; my heart broken beyond repair, and a single liquid shard running down my face.





	You Should Have Lied

**A Seddie Fanfic! I had written for Seddie before, but I think it was a little too angsty for me, so I decided to take it down. Not sure if this should be a oneshot or a multi chap, but for now I'll keep it a one shot. I don't think I want to start a long story quite yet though…Anyway, I know this is suckish, but…yea :P**

**Now, without further ado, here is…**

**You Should Have Lied**

**Inspired by the song by Stephanie Mcintosh**

_It doesn't matter  
That you had the courage to tell me _

_The easy way out _

_Was to free up your guilt, laid it on me _

_What do I care? _

_If it didn't really mean a thing why'd you do it? _

_I'm standing here _

_Looking at someone who doesn't _

_Know they blew it, yeah _

"Sam…I'm so sorry…" the brunette boy laid a comforting hand on my shoulder, but I shook it off. Of all people, I didn't need his sympathy now.

"I don't want to hear it, Fredward. Here's the plan- you forget everything I said this evening, 'kay?"

I walked out of my senior prom with his voice shouting for me to come back; my heart broken beyond repair, and a single liquid shard running down my face.

_[Chorus] _

_You should have lied _

'_Cause your stupid mistake _

_Made my world crash down _

_Now its goodbye _

_No you can't take it back _

_Once the truth has come out of your mouth _

_So you tried to be honest _

_But honesty blew it this time _

_You should have lied _

_You could have lied_

Her words ran through my head all night

"Freddie…I think I, maybe, kinda, feel something for you…"

I reeled back, shocked. "Sam…I'm dating Carly…we can't…you and I…not now…" I stuttered, still shaken by her muttered confession

Her blue eyes hardened once more, and I could see no trace of the hope that had once inhabited them.

"Just…forget it, I guess…" she turned away from me, looking for the exit.

"Sam…I'm so sorry…"

"I don't want to hear it, Fredward. Here's the plan- you forget everything I said this evening, 'kay?" She stormed out, her long blond hair whipping from her right shoulder to her left.

If I was finally dating Carly, the girl I'd been chasing after for years, then why did my heart feel so heavy as I tried, in vain, to call Sam back?

_If a tree falls inside of a forest and nobody hears it _

_It won't affect anybody 'cause no one will miss it _

Maybe it's because I knew that she wouldn't come back this time.

_What would I care _

_If you were dying from the guilt of keeping a secret? _

_This isn't fair _

_'cause now I've gotta be the one dealing with it, oh_

_[Chorus] _

_I don't get it _

_Where was your conscience when _

_You were with her _

_Couldn't you hear it scream out?_

"I quit!" I shouted in my former best friend's face as Carly threw insult after insult into my face, and Freddie stood by, his face obscured by her dark brown hair.

I threw one last, slightly desperate glance at the man I had fallen for, then slammed the door to the iCarly studio for the last time, smirking when I heard the glass on the door shatter and crash to the floor.

_[Chorus] _

_It doesn't matter _

_That you had the courage to tell me_

I, Sam Puckett, was a 22 year old woman on my way to become a real estate agent in a miniscule town in New Jersey. My unplanned child, a result of a drunken one night stand with a man I never saw again, was almost due. I had no friends, having left my former best friend and her boyfriend- surely now husband- and I was still madly in love with that man: Freddie Benson.


End file.
